Quick Answer
Can FMLA leave count against attendance, bonuses, or performance?
An employer generally cannot use protected FMLA leave as a negative factor in attendance discipline, performance reviews, promotions, or other employment decisions. It cannot give you attendance points for protected absences or write you up simply because you used FMLA.
Bonuses are more nuanced. An employer may sometimes deny a bonus based on an objective goal—such as hours worked, products sold, or perfect attendance—if you did not meet that goal because of FMLA leave and the employer treats employees taking equivalent non-FMLA leave the same way.
The question is whether the employer is neutrally applying a genuine rule or using FMLA as a disguised penalty.
Jurisdiction note: This article explains federal FMLA rules that apply in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. State disability, leave, sick-time, wage, and retaliation laws may provide additional protections.
At A Glance
Four rules to remember
- Protected FMLA absences should not generate attendance points.
- FMLA cannot be used as a negative factor in employment decisions.
- Goal-based bonuses may depend on whether the goal was actually achieved.
- Employees on FMLA must be treated consistently with employees on equivalent non-FMLA leave.
FMLA leave cannot be used as a negative factor
The Department of Labor states that an employer may not threaten, punish, suspend, discriminate against, or fire an employee because the employee requested or used FMLA leave.
Its employee-protection guidance specifically identifies examples such as:
- Writing an employee up for missing work while using FMLA;
- Denying a promotion because the employee used FMLA;
- Assessing negative attendance points for FMLA leave; and
- Using leave as a negative factor in another employment decision.
A neutral performance rule is different from a leave penalty. The employer may evaluate real work and legitimate goals, but it may not treat protected leave itself as misconduct, unreliability, or disloyalty.
FMLA Workplace Impact
How FMLA May Affect Attendance, Pay, and Reviews
Protected leave cannot be used as a negative factor, but neutral goal-based rules can be more nuanced.
| Employment Item | Generally Prohibited | Potentially Lawful If Applied Neutrally |
|---|---|---|
| Attendance points | Adding points, occurrences, or discipline because an absence was protected FMLA leave. | Freezing pre-existing points during leave if the same rule applies to comparable non-FMLA leave. |
| Perfect-attendance bonus | Treating FMLA leave worse than equivalent non-FMLA leave. | Denying a goal-based attendance bonus when the goal was not met and equivalent non-FMLA leave is treated the same. |
| Production or sales bonus | Penalizing the employee simply for having used FMLA leave. | Applying a genuine goal-based bonus rule for hours worked or products sold when employees on equivalent leave are treated the same. |
| Performance review | Criticizing “reliability” or output solely because the employee was absent on protected leave. | Evaluating the quality and performance of work actually performed under neutral standards. |
| Promotion | Using FMLA use as a reason not to consider or promote the employee. | Selecting another candidate for a legitimate, documented reason unrelated to FMLA. |
| Pay increase | Withholding an unconditional increase that took effect for comparable employees. | Applying a conditional increase tied to seniority, work performed, or another criterion consistently with equivalent leave. |
Can your employer give you attendance points for FMLA leave?
Generally no. Protected FMLA leave cannot be counted under a no-fault attendance policy as an occurrence that leads to discipline.
For example, if a policy provides a written warning after five absence points, an employer should not include a protected FMLA absence as one of those points.
What about points you already had before leave?
FMLA does not necessarily erase legitimate attendance points that existed before protected leave.
The Department of Labor has also addressed policies that “freeze” existing points during certain types of leave. A freeze may be permissible when employees on FMLA are treated the same as employees on comparable non-FMLA leave. A policy that uniquely extends attendance penalties only because an employee used FMLA is much more problematic.
Can FMLA cost you a perfect-attendance bonus?
Sometimes.
The Department of Labor’s FMLA FAQ explains that an employer may deny a bonus based on achieving a specified goal—such as hours worked, products sold, or perfect attendance—when the employee does not meet that goal because of FMLA leave, as long as employees on equivalent non-FMLA leave are treated the same way.
Example: vacation leave does not disqualify employees
Suppose the employer gives a perfect-attendance bonus even when an employee uses vacation time. If an employee uses paid vacation concurrently with FMLA, the employer generally cannot single out the employee for losing the bonus merely because the vacation was also FMLA-protected.
Example: unpaid leave disqualifies everyone
If the employer’s neutral policy disqualifies any employee who takes unpaid leave from a goal-based bonus, an employee who takes unpaid FMLA may also be ineligible, assuming the employer consistently applies that rule.
The comparison group matters. Employees should obtain the written bonus policy and determine how vacation, sick leave, workers’ compensation leave, personal leave, and other absences are treated.
Can a performance review criticize you for work you missed during FMLA?
An employer can evaluate the quality of the work you actually performed and can address legitimate performance issues that are unrelated to FMLA. FMLA does not excuse poor work, misconduct, or missed requirements that existed independently of protected leave.
But an evaluation can become problematic when the employer effectively penalizes the employee for not producing work during a period when the employee was legally absent.
Examples that may deserve closer review include:
- Calling the employee “unreliable” because of approved FMLA absences;
- Lowering a review score for projects that came due while the employee was on continuous leave;
- Comparing annual raw output without accounting for a lengthy protected absence while claiming the absence itself is the performance problem;
- Criticizing missed meetings that occurred during protected leave; or
- Creating new productivity expectations immediately after the leave request.
What about sales quotas and productivity goals?
There is no universal rule that every productivity target must be prorated in exactly the same way. The key FMLA principle is that leave cannot be used as a negative factor. A neutral, legitimate performance system may still apply to work actually performed, while an employer may violate the law if it structures or applies the system to punish the employee for taking protected leave.
Document how employees on other forms of leave are treated and whether management changed your expectations after learning about FMLA.
Can FMLA hurt your promotion chances?
The employer cannot lawfully refuse to consider you for promotion because you requested or used FMLA leave.
That does not guarantee promotion. The employer may choose another employee for legitimate reasons such as qualifications, experience, documented performance, or business needs.
Evidence becomes important when:
- A manager says the employee has “missed too much time” because of FMLA;
- The employee was a leading candidate before leave and removed from consideration afterward;
- The employer applies a new attendance prerequisite only to the employee who took leave;
- Comparable employees with non-FMLA absences remain eligible; or
- The employer gives changing explanations for the decision.
Can FMLA affect pay raises?
Employees returning from FMLA are generally entitled to the same unconditional pay increases that occurred during leave, such as a company-wide cost-of-living increase.
Conditional increases tied to seniority, work performed, attendance history, or another criterion may depend on how the employer treats employees on equivalent non-FMLA leave.
What evidence should you save?
Evidence Checklist
Compare the rule before and after FMLA
- FMLA approval and designation notices;
- Attendance-point records before and after leave;
- Written attendance policy;
- Bonus plan and eligibility rules;
- Performance reviews from prior years;
- Sales or productivity reports;
- Promotion postings and candidate criteria;
- Emails or messages mentioning leave, reliability, staffing, or attendance;
- Records showing how employees on other types of leave were treated; and
- Any discipline, demotion, pay reduction, or termination records.
How to raise a concern with HR
Keep the complaint specific. For example:
“My attendance record shows two points for June 4 and June 18. Both dates were approved intermittent FMLA absences. Please review and remove any attendance points assessed because of protected FMLA leave. I would also like confirmation that those absences will not be used negatively in my performance review or discipline.”
For a bonus dispute, identify the written policy and ask how employees taking comparable non-FMLA leave are treated.
When does this become FMLA retaliation?
A recordkeeping mistake may be corrected without becoming a lawsuit. A stronger retaliation concern may exist when management knowingly uses protected leave to justify discipline, lower ratings, lost advancement, reduced hours, or termination.
Review the evidence used to prove FMLA retaliation and Swartz Swidler’s guide to common FMLA violations.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Can my employer give me attendance points for intermittent FMLA?
Protected intermittent FMLA absences generally cannot be assessed as negative points under a no-fault attendance policy.
Can my employer count FMLA as an unexcused absence?
Properly protected FMLA leave should not be treated as an unexcused absence for discipline.
Can FMLA cause me to lose an attendance bonus?
Possibly, if the bonus is based on an objective goal that was not met and employees on equivalent non-FMLA leave are treated the same.
Can FMLA reduce my production bonus?
Potentially under a neutral goal-based plan, but FMLA itself cannot be used as a punishment. The plan and treatment of comparable leave matter.
Can my manager lower my performance score because I took leave?
The employer may evaluate legitimate performance but should not use protected leave itself as a negative factor.
Can I be denied a promotion because I used FMLA?
No. FMLA use cannot be a negative factor in the promotion decision. The employer may still choose another candidate for legitimate reasons.
Do I get company-wide raises that happened while I was on leave?
Employees generally are entitled to unconditional pay increases that would have applied had they remained actively employed.
Can old attendance points stay on my record during FMLA?
Legitimate pre-leave points may remain, and some neutral policies may freeze them during leave if comparable leave is treated the same.
What if HR says the computer automatically assessed the point?
Automation does not make a protected-leave penalty lawful. Ask for the record to be corrected and preserve the response.
What if I am fired after the points push me over the termination threshold?
If protected FMLA absences contributed to the threshold, the termination may involve FMLA interference or retaliation and should be reviewed promptly.
Was FMLA used against you?
Swartz Swidler represents employees in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, and South Jersey in FMLA interference and retaliation matters involving attendance points, discipline, performance reviews, promotions, bonuses, and termination.
An employment lawyer can compare the written policy, leave records, treatment of other employees, performance history, and the employer’s stated reason for the decision.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws change, and older articles may not reflect current law. Whether you have a claim depends on your facts and on deadlines that can be short. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
